In 2019, Outside the Huddle introduced our highest preseason honor: the First Eleven. This honor comes on the heels of the basketball version, the ‘First Five,’ which traces its pre-OTH origins back over 35 seasons. It is our hope that the football version follows in that same tradition.
In 2020, the First Eleven became the culmination of our firs- ever Top 50 player countdown.
2025
No. 2: Jarron Taylor, Bishop Luers
No. 3: Jaidon Van Pelt, Carroll
No. 4: Maalik Moore, North Side
No. 5: Jerquaden Guilford, Northrop
No. 7: Ayle Taylor, Bishop Luers
No. 8: Andrew Trahin, Bishop Dwenger
No. 9: Caleb Kiengele, North Side
No. 10: Michael White, Homestead
No. 11: Rylee Biddle, East Noble
2024
No. 3: Jimmy Sullivan, Carroll
No. 4: Stratton Fuller, Columbia City
No. 6: Jamarion Kolagbodi, Snider
No. 8: Charlie Riddle, Heritage
No. 10: Seth Pruitt, West Noble
No. 11: Max Kaehr, Adams Central
2023
No. 1: Brauntae Johnson, North Side
No. 2: Mylan Graham, New Haven
No. 3: Jimmy Sullivan, Carroll
No. 6: Jordan King, North Side
No. 7: Stratton Fuller, Columbia City
No. 8: Ashton Pesetski, Carroll
No. 9: Lukas Rohrbacher, Snider
No. 10: Ajani Washington, New Haven
2022
No. 1: Brauntae Johnson, North Side
No. 2: Mylan Graham, New Haven
No. 4: CJ Davis, Bishop Dwenger
No. 5: Nick Thompson, Bishop Luers
No. 7: Julante Hinton, Northrop
No. 9: Bubba Craig, Concordia Lutheran
No. 10: Dylan Bennett, Carroll
2021
No. 1: Landen Livingston, Leo – Senior, OL
No. 2: Jeffrey Becker, Carroll – Senior, QB
No. 3: Nate Anderson, Homestead – Senior, WR
No. 4: DJ Allen, Leo – Senior DE/TE
No. 5: Rowan Zolman, East Noble – Senior WR/DB
No. 6: Rocco Ciocca, Bishop Dwenger – Senior WR
No. 7: Carson Clark, Bishop Luers – Senior QB
No. 8: Brauntae Johnson, North Side – Sophomore WR
No. 9: DJ Moore, Snider – Senior OL
No. 10: Julante Hinton, Northrop – Sophomore DL
No. 11: Brody Glenn, Bishop Luers – Senior WR
2020
No. 1 Nick Miller, South Adams – Senior, LB/DE
No. 2: Braeden Hardwick, Homestead – Senior, RB
No. 3: Jeff Becker, Carroll – Junior, QB
No. 4: Duce Taylor, North Side – Senior, QB
No. 5: DJ Moore, Snider – Junior, OL/DL
No. 6: Devon Tippmann, Bishop Dwenger – Senior, RB/LB
No. 7: Joe Collier, Adams Central – Senior, DE/TE
No. 8: Vinny Fiacable, Bishop Dwenger, Senior OL/DL/RB
No. 9: Landen Livingston, Leo, Junior OL/DT
No. 10: James Arnold, South Adams, Senior QB
No. 11: Jared Kistler, Homestead, Senior WR
Ryan Brandt, Angola, Senior safety
Gianini Bellzaire, Snider, Senior DL
Griffin Little, Homestead, Senior WR
Hayden Ellinger, Bishop Dwenger, Senior RB/LB
Keshaun Fields, Wayne, Senior RB
Randy Holtz, Snider, Senior OL
Jamic Johnson, Bishop Luers, Senior WR
Bailey Parker, East Noble, Senior QB/DB
Brandon Pruitt, West Noble, Senior RB/LB
Cam Rogers, Homestead, Senior LB/WR
Nick Miller, South Adams, Junior WR/LB