In 2019, Outside the Huddle introduced our highest preseason honor: the First Eleven. This honor comes on the heels of the basketball version, the ‘First Five,’ which traces its pre-OTH origins back over 35 seasons. It is our hope that the football version follows in that same tradition.
In 2020, the First Eleven became the culmination of our first ever Top 50 player countdown.
2025
No. 2: Jarron Taylor, Bishop Luers
No. 3: Jaidon Van Pelt, Carroll
No. 4: Maalik Moore, North Side
No. 5: Jerquaden Guilford, Northrop
No. 7: Ayle Taylor, Bishop Luers
No. 8: Andrew Trahin, Bishop Dwenger
No. 9: Caleb Kiengele, North Side
No. 10: Michael White, Homestead
No. 11: Rylee Biddle, East Noble
2024
No. 3: Jimmy Sullivan, Carroll
No. 4: Stratton Fuller, Columbia City
No. 6: Jamarion Kolagbodi, Snider
No. 8: Charlie Riddle, Heritage
No. 10: Seth Pruitt, West Noble
No. 11: Max Kaehr, Adams Central
2023
No. 1: Brauntae Johnson, North Side
No. 2: Mylan Graham, New Haven
No. 3: Jimmy Sullivan, Carroll
No. 6: Jordan King, North Side
No. 7: Stratton Fuller, Columbia City
No. 8: Ashton Pesetski, Carroll
No. 9: Lukas Rohrbacher, Snider
No. 10: Ajani Washington, New Haven
2022
No. 1: Brauntae Johnson, North Side
No. 2: Mylan Graham, New Haven
No. 4: CJ Davis, Bishop Dwenger
No. 5: Nick Thompson, Bishop Luers
No. 7: Julante Hinton, Northrop
No. 9: Bubba Craig, Concordia Lutheran
No. 10: Dylan Bennett, Carroll
2021
No. 1: Landen Livingston, Leo – Senior, OL
No. 2: Jeffrey Becker, Carroll – Senior, QB
No. 3: Nate Anderson, Homestead – Senior, WR
No. 4: DJ Allen, Leo – Senior DE/TE
No. 5: Rowan Zolman, East Noble – Senior WR/DB
No. 6: Rocco Ciocca, Bishop Dwenger – Senior WR
No. 7: Carson Clark, Bishop Luers – Senior QB
No. 8: Brauntae Johnson, North Side – Sophomore WR
No. 9: DJ Moore, Snider – Senior OL
No. 10: Julante Hinton, Northrop – Sophomore DL
No. 11: Brody Glenn, Bishop Luers – Senior WR
2020
No. 1 Nick Miller, South Adams – Senior, LB/DE
No. 2: Braeden Hardwick, Homestead – Senior, RB
No. 3: Jeff Becker, Carroll – Junior, QB
No. 4: Duce Taylor, North Side – Senior, QB
No. 5: DJ Moore, Snider – Junior, OL/DL
No. 6: Devon Tippmann, Bishop Dwenger – Senior, RB/LB
No. 7: Joe Collier, Adams Central – Senior, DE/TE
No. 8: Vinny Fiacable, Bishop Dwenger, Senior OL/DL/RB
No. 9: Landen Livingston, Leo, Junior OL/DT
No. 10: James Arnold, South Adams, Senior QB
No. 11: Jared Kistler, Homestead, Senior WR
Ryan Brandt, Angola, Senior safety
Gianini Bellzaire, Snider, Senior DL
Griffin Little, Homestead, Senior WR
Hayden Ellinger, Bishop Dwenger, Senior RB/LB
Keshaun Fields, Wayne, Senior RB
Randy Holtz, Snider, Senior OL
Jamic Johnson, Bishop Luers, Senior WR
Bailey Parker, East Noble, Senior QB/DB
Brandon Pruitt, West Noble, Senior RB/LB
Cam Rogers, Homestead, Senior LB/WR
Nick Miller, South Adams, Junior WR/LB